Tuesday, May 29, 2007

Rudy and Realism

My blogmate, Pete Abel, is not as enanmoured with GOP Presidential Candidate Rudy Giuliani. He is also upset that social conservatives are still more concerned about...social issues than about other issues. He is also concerned about Rudy's apporoach on foriegn policy, a hesitation with Rudy that I share.

This brought up a few things:

First, we should understand that in many ways the "realist" school of foreign policy is no longer prominent in Republican circles. The voices we hear now are those from the Ron Paul-Pat Buchanan school (the isolationist/non-interventionist school) and the neoconservative school. Even though the NeoCon school has failed in Iraq, they are still powerful because of writers and institutions that support their "America alone" approach. Ross Douthat notes:

The vacuum that (Ron)Paul currently occupies is supposed to be filled by an internationally-minded realism. Indeed, it's precisely the coexistence of realism and idealism in Republican foreign policy, the fruitful tension between the two strains of thought, that has long made the GOP the party to be trusted in international relations - because the idealists elevate the realists, and the realists keep the idealists grounded. When the pendulum swings too far in one direction or another, this tension has usually produced a correction, of the kind that, say, the original neocons and then Reagan provided to the cynical machtpolitik of Kissinger. But there's no sign of a realist corrective in the current GOP field: There were ten candidates on that stage besides Ron Paul yesterday night, and not one of them was willing to call the Iraq War a mistake, which seems to me like the place that a serious realist critique of his Presidency's foreign policy needs to begin.

The fact is, we don't have a Brent Scrowcroft school of foriegn policy in the GOP anymore, or at least not in the number that they once were. There is no realist candidate in the GOP field. A realist would have long ago decided that the war in Iraq was going no where and would find a way to extricate themselves from the situation. There is one potential canidate out there that could be the person Pete (and I) are looking for: Nebraskan Senator Chuck Hagel. It would be nice if he got in the race, because he is the voice in the GOP we need at this time. Neocon foriegn policy has not worked. It's time flip the script.

If we are interested in getting a "realist Republican" running for President, then maybe people should join the "draft Hagel" movement. (I'm looking at you, Pete.)


cumberland said...

Cynicism and defeatism are NOT options to be entertained.
"We are in the eleventh hour of losing this Nation..."

Consider the only Conservative Presidential Candidate...

Welcome my name is: Joel Lemieux I am retired and currently live

in the beautiful mountains of Western NC... I Have been an avid

supporter of Dr Ron Paul... "We have to get Ron Paul elected,

firstly and foremost, in the primaries"... Then on to the



However, if this is to come about (Ron Paul 2008) we will require

a war chest... We are attempting to get (1) one Million people to

send Ron Paul only $7.00 each per Month... Thanks... Joel...


Meanwhile Consider The Following:

Our Only Choice!!! Leadership 2008

Can Ron Paul Win? On The Issues - A Resounding YES!

Knowing this let us then look at the most important benefit… that

Ron Paul brings to the Presidency...


Leadership is Action Through *Example Not Position...

(It is not a position of power nor being in the right place at the

right time, neither define leadership).

It is defined by setting the example through taking action on such

Leadership Traits as Truthfulness! Honesty! Fidelity!

Ron Paul Has Acted Admirably On All These Leadership Traits:

“Truthfulness” first and foremost… Then: Principle, Integrity,

Honesty,* Fidelity (to their oaths), Honor, Virtue, Compassion,

Courage, Vision, Wisdom and Faith.


Can anyone bring forth any other candidate (GOP or DEM, etc.) that

can lay claim to all of these characteristics?

I believe we are all hard pressed to do so... “Strike That”. I

"KNOW" we ARE hard pressed!

Check out this site it may give you some promo assistance... It

has a promo area where everything can be printed out for free...

It also has "send to friends" area for e-mailing... Hope this

helps you ...


Get the word out "SHARE" with your friends... And don't forget the

$7 per Month "we all can afford that" remember each of us do not

need to get thousands of people... just set a weekly goal and

have any/all of your friends duplicate your efforts... It will be

persistence and perseverance that will elect Ron Paul...

PS: Start with flyers at the Universities put one on each and

every bulletin board on campus also look for support from the

student GOP... Then have them go to other campus's... Also, don't

forget High School Seniors- by the time elections roll around they

will be old enough to vote!

Charlie said...

You are quite right that the Republican party needs to get away from the isolationist and the neoconservative foreign policy. Of the '08 candidates and potential candidates, Hagel hands down has the best foreign policy.